esköre™

InsightsLLC Formation & Filings14 min readNovember 15, 2026

US LLC for Canadians in Toronto: Tax Check First, Then the Paperwork

A Toronto founder can own a US LLC, but the tax position should be settled before any paperwork starts. This guide covers the tax questions, the LLC versus Ontario corporation decision and the formation steps in order.

LLC Formation & Filings at Eskore
Photo by Unsplash on Unsplash

US LLC for Canadians in Toronto: a Toronto or GTA founder can own a US LLC, but the tax position should be settled before any paperwork starts. This guide puts the tax questions first, then walks through formation in the order it should happen.

Eskore is a digital and technology studio with offices in Toronto, Thornhill, London and New York. We build custom software, websites, apps and cloud infrastructure, and we handle company formation through our LLC Formation & Filings service. We are not a tax firm, and nothing in this article is tax advice. Tax questions belong with a cross-border accountant.

Can a Canadian own a US LLC from Toronto? Yes, with conditions

Yes. A Canadian resident or citizen can form a US LLC and own all of it. No US citizenship, US residency or Social Security number (SSN) is required. You don't need to live in the US, work there or visit it to form one.

The conditions are practical rather than a gate. Every formation needs a registered agent with a physical address in the state where the company is formed. The steps that involve the IRS and banks have their own requirements, which change over time. Both are covered below.

The real decision is tax. Forming the company is straightforward. What the company means for your tax position in Canada and the US is not, and that's where your thinking should go first.

No citizenship, residency or SSN needed

Nationality and residency don't restrict who can own a US LLC. A non-US person can be the sole member of a single-member LLC, and forming it doesn't require you to be in the US.

Two requirements often get mistaken for eligibility rules. They aren't, but they shape the process:

  • The registered agent. Every state requires a registered agent with a physical address in the state where the LLC is formed. That's a service address for legal notices, not your home address. A PO box won't do.
  • The EIN and bank onboarding. Each has its own requirements, which vary by institution and change over time. Check them before you start, not halfway through.

Canada has no LLC; the real comparison is an Ontario corporation

Canada has no LLC. The LLC exists only in US law. So when a Toronto founder asks about a US LLC, the real question is whether to form a US entity or a Canadian one.

For an Ontario founder, the fair comparison is a US LLC against an Ontario corporation, or a federal corporation under the Canada Business Corporations Act. Treat it as one decision with two options, not two separate products. The place of formation determines the filings, tax and banking on each side of the border.

Settle the tax questions before you file anything

Most founders don't need a tax answer to set up a company. They need the right questions asked before the company exists, because some decisions are much harder to reverse afterwards.

Take this checklist to a cross-border accountant. It frames the appointment. It doesn't replace their answers.

  1. Where do you live now, and where do you expect to live over the next few years?
  2. Where will the income come from: US customers, Canadian customers or both?
  3. Who will own the company, in what shares, and are partners or investors likely?
  4. Will the business have a US presence, such as an office, staff, inventory or a warehouse?
  5. Will the company make a tax classification election, and if so, when?
  6. Which parts of the Canada–US tax treaty could apply to your situation?
  7. Which filings are needed in each country, and when are they due?
  8. What changes if you move, or if ownership changes later?

Question 1 alone can change the answer. Don't assume any one item is the deciding factor.

Double taxation depends on your facts

Canada and the US don't always classify the same entity the same way. The CRA generally treats a US LLC as a corporation for Canadian purposes. In the US, a single-member LLC is disregarded for income tax by default unless its owner elects otherwise. The gap between those two positions is where double taxation can arise.

Whether it does in your case depends on residency, where the income comes from, who owns the company and how the treaty applies. We won't tell you which outcome applies to you. We don't know your facts, and anyone who gives a definitive answer without asking them is guessing.

Form 5472 and pro forma 1120, even with no income

A foreign-owned single-member US LLC generally has an annual federal filing: Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120. The obligation applies even when the company has no income and no activity. Nothing shows up on a bank statement, so it's easy to forget, and filing nothing isn't an option.

Under the IRS rules for Form 5472, the penalty for failing to file a complete and timely return is $25,000 per form, with further penalties if the failure continues after an IRS notice. The filing is due on the 15th day of the fourth month after the tax year ends, which is April 15 for calendar-year companies. Filing Form 7004 gives an automatic six-month extension. Confirm the deadline and extension rules against the current IRS instructions each year, and don't plan around a date you remember from last time.

When to bring in a cross-border accountant

Bring the accountant in before you form the company, not after. Choose one who works with both Canadian and US filings, and ask directly whether they have prepared Form 5472 filings and Canadian corporate returns for clients in your position.

Bring these with you:

  • Your ownership plan, including any future partners
  • Expected income for the first two years, and where your customers are
  • Whether you plan to live in or move to the US
  • Any existing Canadian company you would keep

With that information, the accountant can answer the structure question directly, and the formation work won't run ahead of the tax answer.

LLC or Ontario corporation: the decision in one table

The table sets out the factors that usually matter. Where a row touches tax, the answer belongs to your accountant.

Factor US LLC Ontario or federal corporation
Where it's formed A US state you choose Ontario, or federally under the CBCA
Legal existence Exists only in US law Exists in Canadian law
Address requirement Registered agent with a physical address in the formation state Registered office in the province of incorporation
Ongoing filings State annual reports, agent renewal, and for foreign-owned single-member LLCs the federal Form 5472 with pro forma 1120 Annual filings with the relevant registry, and corporate returns with the CRA
How it's taxed Depends on your facts; the two countries can classify the entity differently Taxed as a corporation in Canada; any US position depends on your facts
Banking Requirements vary by bank; some need an in-person visit Familiar in Canada; US banking has its own steps
Investor expectations Some investors are less familiar with LLCs than with corporations Depends on who you're raising from
Administrative load Two-country compliance plus agent renewal Canadian filings, plus any US filings if you trade there

The tax rows are for your accountant. The rest is where a structuring conversation helps. Our Consultancy & Strategy team can help you map the decision. That conversation doesn't replace tax advice.

Choosing a US state for your LLC: Wyoming, Delaware and New Mexico

The state where you form the LLC drives the fees, the annual reporting and the registered agent requirement. It also shapes how banks and investors see the company.

The lowest formation fee isn't automatically the right choice. A low fee with high ongoing costs, or a state that doesn't suit your investor plans, can cost more over the life of the company.

We haven't printed state fees in this article, because they change and the figures in circulation don't agree. Check each one on the state's own site before you budget.

Wyoming

Wyoming is a common choice for non-residents, and most guides start there. Confirm the formation fee and the annual report fee on the Wyoming Secretary of State site.

One detail catches people out. The foreign LLC registration fee applies to an LLC formed in another state that registers to do business in Wyoming. It does not apply to an LLC formed in Wyoming. Check which one applies to you before you budget. A Wyoming LLC still needs a registered agent in Wyoming.

Delaware

Delaware suits companies planning outside investment or a more complex structure, where investors and lawyers are used to its corporate law. For a solo founder building a first product, it is often more structure than the company needs. That's a judgement about your plan, not a rule.

Delaware charges an annual LLC tax. Take the current amount from corp.delaware.gov, not from a comparison article.

New Mexico

New Mexico is often presented as a lower-cost formation option. Confirm the formation fee with the New Mexico Secretary of State. Treat it as one line in your budget, not your first-year total. The registered agent, state reporting and federal filings all add to the figure.

We've kept this comparison to three states. If another state is on your shortlist, check its registration and presence requirements on that state's official corporations site before you commit.

The formation steps, in order

Formation is a sequence, and the order matters:

  1. Choose the state, after working through the tax questions above.
  2. File the Articles of Organization with the state.
  3. Appoint a registered agent in the formation state.
  4. Apply for the EIN with the IRS.
  5. Prepare and sign the operating agreement.
  6. Open the bank account.

Our LLC Formation & Filings service covers these steps, as set out in the written scope you agree before work starts. The tax position stays with your accountant.

Articles of Organization and the registered agent

The Articles of Organization are the filing that creates the LLC. You file them with the state, and that filing brings the company into existence under that state's law.

Every state requires a registered agent with a physical address in the state where the LLC is formed. The agent receives legal notices and official mail for the company. It's an annual cost, not a one-off, so budget for it every year. Choose an agent you expect to still be serving in three years. If the agent lapses or changes without you noticing, notices get missed and the company can fall out of good standing.

Getting an EIN without an SSN

An EIN is the federal employer identification number the IRS issues to a company. A non-US founder without an SSN can apply using Form SS-4. Which route is open to you, whether online, by phone, by fax or through a formation service, depends on your situation and the IRS process in force when you apply. Check the current EIN guidance on irs.gov before you start.

The application asks for company details, so it normally follows formation. Whether a US address makes the application smoother is a question for the current IRS process, not something to build your timeline on.

Operating agreement

Even a single-owner LLC needs a written operating agreement. It sets out how the company is run, who has authority and how ownership changes. Banks often ask for it, and it becomes essential if you take on partners or if anyone later questions whether the company is separate from you.

Eskore prepares the operating agreement with you. The content decisions, including ownership terms, transfer rules and what happens if you step away, are yours and your advisers'. We draft the document. We don't make those calls for you.

Opening the bank account

Banks typically ask for a passport, the EIN letter, the Articles of Organization and the operating agreement. Use those as your checklist.

Requirements vary by institution and change over time. Some banks require an in-person visit, even for non-resident owners. Ask your bank for its current requirements for non-resident business owners before you book, including whether it can onboard you remotely. The bank you use in Toronto may run a different process for a US business account.

What it costs: the lines to separate

Vendor bundles mix these items together, so the total looks simpler than it is. Ask each provider for every line separately.

Cost line What it covers Where to confirm
State formation fee Articles of Organization filing Secretary of State for the state you choose
Foreign LLC registration Only for an LLC formed in another state and registered to do business in the new state Secretary of State where you register
Registered agent Service address in the formation state, renewed each year Agent's written quote
State annual report Ongoing state filing State's official website
EIN IRS application Current IRS EIN guidance; check whether any formation service charges a separate fee
Banking Account opening and monthly fees Bank's current fee schedule
Operating agreement Drafting with you Your written scope with Eskore
Federal annual filing Form 5472 with pro forma 1120 Your accountant's written quote
Canadian filings Returns that may apply to your structure Your cross-border accountant

Add the lines up twice: once for year one, and once for a recurring year. The recurring costs are the ones that catch owners out. Our fee is fixed in the written scope before any work starts, so you'll see the line items before you commit.

Annual compliance calendar

Compliance is what keeps the company in good standing. Deadlines and extension rules change, so confirm each one with the relevant authority every year.

Item Applies to Check with
Form 5472 with pro forma 1120 Foreign-owned single-member US LLCs, including those with no income IRS: due April 15 for calendar-year companies; Form 7004 for a six-month extension
Form 8832 classification election LLCs that elect a classification other than the default IRS
State annual report Every state-formed LLC Each state's Secretary of State
Registered agent renewal Every LLC Agent and state
Canadian corporate return (T2) Canadian corporations, where one is involved CRA: generally due six months after fiscal year-end
T1134 information return Canadian reporting entities with foreign affiliates CRA: confirm whether it applies to your structure, and when
Beneficial ownership reporting (BOI) Currently not required for a Toronto-owned, US-formed LLC (see below) FinCEN

On the Form 8832 election: an election can take effect up to 75 days before it is filed, or up to 12 months after. That window sets how far back the effective date can reach. It is not a filing deadline. Confirm the current rules in the IRS instructions, and let your accountant decide whether an election makes sense at all.

On BOI: a US LLC formed in a state is a domestic reporting company. Under FinCEN's March 2025 interim final rule, domestic companies are exempt from BOI reporting, and foreign ownership doesn't change that. So a Toronto-owned, US-formed LLC does not currently have to file a BOI report. FinCEN has said it will finalise the rule, and the final text could differ, so check FinCEN's BOI page on the day you file.

Timeline: about four weeks, with stated assumptions

This timeline is dated as of 15 November 2026. It assumes the state is chosen, your documents are complete, no extra identity or compliance checks are required, and the bank approves the application without delay. If any of those assumptions fail, the timeline moves.

Sources give conflicting ranges, from a few business days for some filings to several weeks for the full set-up, and they don't agree on what each figure includes. We plan on about four weeks end to end, including the bank, and treat shorter figures as best case.

Window (from start) Step Notes
Week 1 Tax questions answered; state chosen; Articles filed; registered agent appointed Accountant's answers come before filing
Weeks 1–2 EIN application submitted Route depends on the current IRS process
Week 2 Operating agreement reviewed and signed Content decisions are yours and your advisers'
Weeks 2–4 Bank application and documents submitted Varies by bank; some require an in-person visit
Week 4 Bank account open, subject to bank approval Assumes no delays from the state, IRS or bank

State and agency processing times vary, so treat these windows as planning assumptions, not promises.

What Eskore handles, and what your accountant handles

Eskore handles, under your written scope:

  • Preparing and filing the formation documents with the state
  • Arranging the registered agent
  • Requesting the EIN through the current IRS process
  • Preparing the operating agreement with you
  • Organising the banking documents and the bank application pack

Your accountant handles:

  • The cross-border tax position and any classification decisions
  • Canadian and US filings, including Form 5472 with pro forma 1120 and any Canadian returns
  • Whether an LLC or a Canadian corporation fits your facts

Eskore is a digital and technology studio, not a tax firm. Tax questions go to your accountant, and we'll help you bring the right information to that conversation. If you're also choosing who will build the software behind the business, our guide to choosing a custom software developer for your small business in Toronto covers that decision separately. We work from our Toronto and Thornhill offices, and from London and New York. Every engagement starts with a written scope and a fixed price, agreed before any work begins, so you know what's included before anything is filed.

Next step: book a scoping call for your US LLC

For Toronto founders weighing a US LLC for Canadians, the sensible first step is a conversation, not a filing. In a free 30-minute scoping call, we'll talk through the state, the LLC versus corporation question and the paperwork, and tell you honestly whether we're the right team for it. If you've already settled the tax questions with your accountant and you're ready to form the company, book a free 30-minute scoping call and we'll put the scope in writing before any work starts.

Questions

Need help with this?

Talk to our llc formation & filings team.