The questions to ask before hiring a local SEO company should test three things: whether the firm can show where your business ranks across your whole service area, whether you still control your Google Business Profile once work starts, and whether you can leave without losing what you paid to build. This article gives you eleven questions, a good answer and a bad answer for each, and a scorecard you can use on a 30-minute call with every firm on your shortlist.
Why hiring a local SEO company is harder to judge than it looks
Local rankings change street by street. A plumbing company in North York may rank well near its office and barely appear in Scarborough, where much of its work comes from. A dental clinic in Austin can look strong on one search and weak across the neighbourhoods it actually serves. A single search run from the office tells you very little about either.
Reports can also look good while the phone stays quiet. A table of keyword positions is easy to produce and easy to misread. Picture a roofing company in Denver whose agency sends a monthly deck showing top-three positions for a dozen terms. Six months in, calls are flat, and the Google Business Profile sits under the agency's email address. Nothing in that deck would have told the owner the hire was a mistake.
Use the questions below in order. They follow the sequence in which local SEO work tends to go wrong. Ask each firm for two references from businesses in your trade and city, and call them.
- How will you measure our rankings across our service area?
- Which keywords and neighbourhoods will you target first?
- Who owns our Google Business Profile, and who holds access?
- What happens if the profile is suspended or stuck in verification?
- What will the monthly report show?
- What will you build on our site and in our listings, and what won't you do?
- Do you post, buy or incentivize reviews?
- What schema and technical work will you do?
- How long until results are realistic, and what are the minimum term and notice?
- What happens to access, reports and content when the contract ends?
- What does the monthly fee cover?
Map pack: how will you measure rankings across your service area?
Ask how the agency tracks rankings from several points across your service area, not from one search run at the office. Grid-based tracking places a set of points over a map, runs the same search from each point and records where your business appears. Local Falcon is one tool that does this. Without a grid, you cannot see that you rank well in one neighbourhood and poorly in the next.
This matters most when the service area is wide. An HVAC company in Raleigh might rank well on the street where its shop sits and fall to page two in Cary or Apex, where many of its jobs are booked. A single-location check would miss that entirely. If you want the grid work done for you, our Local SEO & Maps Ranking service covers tracking, the keyword plan and the reporting.
Good answer: The agency names the keywords it will track, states the grid size and point spacing, and sets the grid to your real service radius. It compares you against named local competitors on the same grid, and it commits to a fixed update cadence, such as every two weeks or monthly. It shows you the map, not just a score.
Bad answer: A promise to put your business first in the city, or one screenshot from one search. A screenshot tells you nothing about most of your service area.
Which keywords and neighbourhoods come first?
Rankings follow search demand. Ask for a list of service terms and neighbourhood terms that people actually search, with some evidence behind each one, and a plan for which page targets which term.
Good answer: A short, specific list tied to your services and areas, such as "emergency plumber North York" or "family dentist Austin", with one local page for each real service area. The pages describe work done in that area. The choices draw on data you already have, such as where your calls and enquiries come from today.
Bad answer: The same generic phrase, such as "best plumber", repeated across every city you serve with only the town name swapped in. Visitors read those pages as thin, and search engines gain little from them.
If you also need paid ads and content alongside SEO, our Digital Marketing service covers all three.
Who owns your Google Business Profile, and who has access
Your Google Business Profile holds your reviews, photos, listing history and the phone number linked to your business. Who controls it matters more than most owners expect.
Google's help page on owners and managers sets out the roles. A profile can have several owners but only one primary owner. Owners can add and remove users. Managers cannot add or remove users, and they cannot remove the profile. (Google Business Profile Help)
Whitespark's guide to business settings recommends that the business itself holds Primary Owner access, ideally through an email address on its own domain, so the account survives staff changes. (Whitespark)
Good answer: You remain Primary Owner, using a company email. The agency is added as a manager, and you can remove it at any time. The agency lists the profile tasks it will handle, such as categories, services, posts, Q&A and review responses, and it does not need your owner login to do them.
Bad answer: A request for your owner login or password, or a plan for the agency to become primary owner. A profile created under the agency's email, with your business listed beneath it, is the same problem. If that account is lost, so is the history and the route back to control.
Our Google Business Profile setup and management service runs on the same terms: you keep control of the profile.
What if the profile is suspended or stuck in verification?
Few agency checklists ask this question. Suspensions and verification problems happen, and the wrong first move can slow recovery.
Good answer: The agency works through these points:
- Diagnosis first. It can tell a suspension from a disabled profile, a verification hold and a duplicate listing. Each needs a different response.
- Evidence. It gathers documents that show the business is real and operates at the address listed, such as business registration, utility bills, signage and photos of the premises.
- Duplicates. It finds duplicate listings and resolves them through the correct route, rather than creating a new profile to replace the old one. How to Remove a Duplicate Google Business Profile Safely covers that route.
- Address. It checks whether the address meets Google's requirements for a business location. A virtual office or mailbox can cause trouble, and a service-area business may need to hide its address. Changing the address to get around a block can make things worse. Our guide to keeping, hiding or moving a virtual office address explains the options.
- Restraint. It does not file repeated appeals or open new profiles while the first is under review.
Bad answer: "We'll set up a new listing," or a promise that the profile will definitely be reinstated. Also bad: a firm that asks you to sign before it has looked at the profile.
If you are already in this position, our GMB Suspension & Reinstatement service covers diagnosis, evidence and appeals. For the step-by-step route, read How to Reinstate a Suspended Google Business Profile in 2026. If calls and directions have already dropped off, Calls and Directions Gone? Triage a Suspended Google Maps Listing in 48 Hours is a useful first read.
What the monthly report should show, beyond rankings
A monthly report should answer one question: did the local work bring in people who might buy? Rankings are an input. Calls, direction requests and enquiries are the output.
A useful monthly report includes:
- calls made from the profile
- direction requests
- website clicks from the profile
- form enquiries and booked calls, with the source where you can trace it
- organic performance from Search Console: impressions, clicks, and the pages and queries behind them
- grid rankings for the agreed keywords, shown on the map
Set a baseline before any work starts. Export six to twelve months of profile insights and Search Console data so you can compare like with like. Without a baseline, every report is a snapshot with nothing to measure against.
For an audit, read-only Search Console access is usually enough. Full access is only needed to make changes, and the property should stay in your name. Ask which level the agency needs and why. Many agencies use BrightLocal to report on listing accuracy and reviews. Ask which reports they run and how often.
Good answer: Calls and enquiries sit next to rankings, and the agency explains what moved and why.
Bad answer: Keyword positions with no link to calls, enquiries or revenue, or a long run of charts with no summary.
Local pages, citations and reviews
Local pages. Ask how many pages they will build, what each one will cover and who checks the facts. A good service-area page describes the work done there, the response times you can honestly keep and the local detail a customer cares about. If the pages need building into your site, our Web Development team can do that.
Citations. These are listings on directories and data sites. The job is making sure your business name, address and phone number (NAP) match everywhere they appear. Ask which tools they use to audit and build citations. BrightLocal and Whitespark are common choices.
Good answer: A short, checked list of relevant directories, an audit showing where your details disagree and a plan to correct them.
Bad answer: Bulk submission to hundreds of directories, many of them low quality. Ask directly: "Will you create duplicate listings or submit us to hundreds of low-quality directories?" A credible firm says no and explains why. Mismatched and duplicate listings weaken trust with customers and with search engines.
Reviews. Ask how the agency asks for them.
Good answer: Every customer is asked through a simple, consistent process, such as a link sent after a job or a QR code on an invoice. The agency helps draft responses to reviews, good and bad.
Bad answer: Review gating (asking only the customers you expect to be happy, or steering unhappy ones to a private form), buying reviews, staff reviewing their own business, or paying for reviews. Google's policies prohibit these, and they can get a profile suspended.
Schema and technical SEO to expect
Schema is structured data: code that describes your business to search engines in a standard format. Schema.org defines a LocalBusiness type that can carry your name, address, phone number, opening hours, website URL and the areas you serve. Structured data does not guarantee rankings, but it makes your details unambiguous, and it must match what the page shows.
Good answer: The agency names the fields it will mark up (name, address, phone, hours, service area and URL are the usual ones), says which pages get the markup and shows you the markup before it goes live. It explains how it will check the result, such as Google's Rich Results Test and the structured data reports in Search Console. It also checks that NAP details match across your site, your profile and your main listings.
Bad answer: "We add schema to everything," with no list of fields and no plan to check it. Markup that describes things the page does not show is worse than none.
Timelines, contract terms and exit
Ask how long results usually take for a business like yours, and ask the firm to explain its reasoning. A good answer names the factors: how competitive the area is, how strong your profile and reviews already are, how many pages need building and how often the grid is checked. It should not promise a date.
Ask about the minimum term and the notice period. If the minimum is a year, ask why. Some firms need time to build citations, reviews and local pages. Others use a long term to lock in fees. A good answer ties the term to the work plan and says what you should expect at each stage.
The most important question is about exit: what happens to access, reports, citations and content when the contract ends?
Good answer: You keep Primary Owner of the profile, admin access to your website, domain and Search Console property. You receive the reports, the citation list, the keyword and grid history and any content written for your site. Notice terms are written down. Ask how your customer data is stored and whether it is deleted on request.
Eskore's standard is that clients own their code and accounts. For local SEO retainers, scope is agreed in writing before work starts, so check that the exit terms are written into that scope before you sign.
Bad answer: "The profile stays with us," or "we'd need to discuss that later." Also bad: reports or citation data that only the agency can export.
What the monthly retainer should include
Ask what the monthly fee includes, in writing. A fair fee can be explained line by line:
- the number of local pages or content pieces each month
- citation audit and building work
- review request set-up and response support
- grid rank tracking, including keyword count and update frequency
- reporting frequency, and whether a review call is included
- whether profile changes are included or billed separately
Ask which currency each firm invoices in, whether taxes apply and whether anything is charged on top of the retainer. If you pay in CAD to a US firm, or the reverse, ask who carries the exchange-rate risk.
Published price guides for local SEO vary widely, and many are written by agencies selling the service. Judge quotes by what they include, not by a benchmark from a blog.
Bad answer: A single monthly figure with no list of deliverables, or one that cannot be explained line by line.
The scorecard and when to walk away
Score each of the eleven questions 0 for a bad answer, 1 for a partial answer and 2 for a good one. The total is out of 22.
| # | Question | 2 points (good) | 1 point (partial) | 0 points (bad) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Map-pack measurement | Grid tracking across the service area, named keywords, stated grid size, named competitors, fixed cadence | Grid mentioned, but size, keywords or cadence unclear | One search from the office, or a first-place promise |
| 2 | Keywords and neighbourhoods | Specific service and area terms tied to demand and your call data; one page per real area | Sensible terms with no evidence, or a few generic pages | Same phrase repeated across cities |
| 3 | Profile ownership | You stay Primary Owner on a company email; agency added as manager | Agency offered as manager, but unclear who holds primary owner | Asks for your owner login or primary ownership |
| 4 | Suspension handling | Diagnoses the type, gathers evidence, resolves duplicates correctly, checks the address | Describes steps in general terms with no diagnosis process | New listing as the first step, or promises reinstatement |
| 5 | Reporting | Calls, directions, enquiries and Search Console against a baseline | Rankings plus some profile actions, not linked to enquiries | Keyword positions only |
| 6 | Pages and citations | Real service-area pages; NAP checked across listings; directories chosen, not bulk | Pages and citations described, with no audit or fixed list | Bulk low-quality submissions or city-name swaps |
| 7 | Reviews | Every customer asked through a simple process; help with responses | Help with responses only, unclear on requests | Buys, fakes, gates or incentivizes reviews |
| 8 | Schema and technical | Names the LocalBusiness fields, shows markup before launch, checks it after | Mentions schema without fields or checks | "We do schema," with no detail |
| 9 | Timeline and term | Reasoned timeline, no date promised, term and notice in writing | Timeline vague, or term not tied to the work | Date guarantee, or unexplained year-long minimum |
| 10 | Exit terms | You keep profile, accounts, reports, citation list and content | Some items returned, others unclear | Profile or data stays with the agency |
| 11 | Fee scope | Fee tied to listed deliverables, currency and extras stated | Fee listed, deliverables loose | Single figure, no deliverables |
Walk away if the total is below 15, or if a firm scores 0 on question 1, 3 or 7, whatever its total. Also end the call if the firm pressures you to sign before anyone has looked at your profile, or if it will not name the tools it uses.
Using the scorecard on the call. Allow about 30 minutes. Send the eleven questions in advance if the firm will accept them. Ask for a sample grid report and a sample monthly report, and ask to see both. Write each answer as close to the firm's own wording as you can, then score it straight after the call while it is fresh. Use the same sheet for every firm on your shortlist, so you compare like with like. If a firm talks well but cannot show a sample grid report, score question 1 as a 1 until it can.
Next step: use these questions before you hire
Use the questions to ask before hiring a local SEO company to narrow your shortlist, and score every firm on the same sheet. Eskore works with business owners across Canada and the US from offices in Toronto, Thornhill, London and New York. You can see examples of past work on our case studies page. If you would like us to look at your shortlist, or at a profile that is already having trouble, book a free 30-minute scoping call. We will go through your service area, your current profile and your reporting, and tell you where the gaps are.